DND Report: Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) has historically been in favour of a separate province of South Punjab and contested at least four elections with the slogan of providing a separate administrative unit to the people of South Punjab, which is geographically linked to the province of Sindh.
The PPP has also supported the creation of a separate province/administrative unit of Hazara by carving it out of KP. However, the same party has taken an extreme position on the separation of urban Sindh from rural Sindh. What a mockery of the party’s stated position on the same issue with two different slogans! Is this not hypocritical politics?
When the PPP previously supported the creation of a South Punjab province, it justified this difference by stating that the demand for South Punjab enjoyed broad consensus among the region’s elected representatives, whereas dividing Sindh lacked consensus among the province’s broader population and provincial legislature.
Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari opposes carving new provinces out of existing ones—particularly the division of Sindh—arguing that such a move violates constitutional procedures, lacks political consensus and fails to address Pakistan’s core economic and governance crises. On one point, he is right: new administrative units would become a burden on the federation if governance issues were not addressed through an overhaul of the entire civil administrative structure. A streamlined civil bureaucracy would bring greater financial and administrative benefits than the existing system. He is also right that political consensus is needed for carving new provinces out of existing ones.
He should, therefore, support the proposed referendum to ascertain public opinion on the creation of new provinces and help build political consensus. He should respect the reality that political consensus does not mean the consensus of political parties alone; rather, it means the consensus of the public. Why, then, is the PPP opposed to seeking the public’s mandate and opinion on this critical issue?
Moreover, political consensus does not mean that this is the prerogative of the PPP alone. Other political parties, such as Jamaat-e-Islami and Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P), have long been demanding a separate urban province. The PPP’s illogical stance on new provinces appears to be an attempt to protect its 50-year electoral stronghold in Sindh, while Bilawal Bhutto frames his opposition around constitutional, economic and security arguments rather than partisan survival.
Bilawal Bhutto has gone too far and warned that any “forced” attempt to divide Sindh against the will of its people would have severe security consequences, stating that imposed divisions could lead to bloodshed on the streets of Karachi.
The PPP is merely protecting its political turf by relying on specific constitutional and historical justifications, particularly Article 239 of the Constitution. Under Pakistan’s Constitution, altering the boundaries of a province cannot be done through a federal executive order or a simple referendum. It requires a two-thirds majority in both Houses of Parliament, as well as a two-thirds majority vote in the affected provincial assembly. Because the PPP holds a commanding majority in the Sindh Assembly, it argues that its opposition is a legitimate exercise of constitutional provincial autonomy.
Bilawal Bhutto is silent on the possible question that could be raised through a referendum: whether there should be new provinces or not. If the answer is in favour of new provinces, then provincial assemblies should respect the public demand and proceed with passing resolutions for the creation of new provinces under Article 239(4).
Pakistan must not remain hostage to political parties and their power structures. Rather, it should move forward, and, for that matter, the Constitution must be amended to accommodate emerging demands.
