Pakistan’s climate crisis – a security problem?

OpinionPakistan’s climate crisis - a security problem?

By Qurat-Ul-Ain Shabbir

Climate change concerns are increasingly being regarded as security challenges requiring rapid response in the context of security and foreign policy discussions. However, the traditional security sector does not offer any durable solution to address climate change and other environmental issues. Mainly because security can introduce a zero-sum rationality to the environmental debate that can create winners and losers and undermine the cooperative efforts required by environmental problems, in addition to the fact that national security practices and institutions are insufficient and not well equipped to address environmental problems. It is therefore contended that only by firmly keeping it within civil society’s domain, a policy to handle climate change can be created and maintained.

Effective environmental governance is essential to addressing the main environmental concerns of Pakistan. This requires the commitment and sincere participation of civil society. The public’s opinions and concerns can be expressed in new and powerful ways through civil society created platforms. It offers a potent tool for advancing common environmental goals and values. The public’s understanding of environmental challenges, the promotion of creative ideas and methods, and the promotion of transparency and non-corrupt behavior in environmental decision-making are all key functions of civil society.

Historically Awareness regarding climate change mostly depends on civil society around the world. Feminist organizations have always taken the lead. Due to socioeconomic inequalities, women are among the populations most susceptible to the consequences of climate change. Organizations like Greenpeace (1971), Union of concerned scientists (1969) and Environmental defense fund (1967) pushed the environment into the national and international political agenda almost 5 decades ago. The World Trade Organization summit in Seattle served as evidence that civil society’s activism can push sustainable growth agenda into the mainstream.

The work of the Copenhagen School is pertinent to the ongoing debate of whether securitizing climate issues or not. Since it directly addresses environmental issues and takes into account the effects of extending the security agenda. Furthermore, it has influenced political and scholarly discourse regarding the danger of defining environmental issues in terms of security. The term “security” designates a set of procedures and a method of handling a problem that define an issue as a security issue. Regardless of context or speaker intentions, the word security connotes a particular logic or rationality. Emergency, necessity, and survival are all aspects of security. It permits the use of extraordinary measures, the flouting of otherwise binding laws, and the use of decrees as opposed to democratic decision making. Whereas issue of climate change requires consensus among people from all walks of life. Deliberate framing should be used as a tactic to break the deadlock on how to deal with the effects of climate change, mend political rifts, pinpoint shared and opposing interests, and create group responses to climate change. For instance, the issue of construction of dams in Pakistan is one such issue which lack consensus among all stake holders. In such situation civil society can play its role as a mediator to highlight merit and demerits of dams’ constructions and build a broad consensus on the issue in society.

It will also be beneficial to support members of civil society in avoiding indivisiveness on issues relating to the climate change. Because of lack of credibility with the general public, authorities and government representatives typically are ineffective at fostering consensus. Therefore, a state can effectively manage its strategic communication by aiding credible groups and individuals with resources, facilitations, and assistance.

In decision GCSS.VII/5 of the seventh special session of the Governing Council/Global Ministers of the Environment Forum, a definition of civil society was provided. Farmers, women, the scientific and technological community, youth, indigenous people and communities, workers and trade unions, business and industry, non-governmental organizations, as well as local governments are some of the primary groups that make up civil society.

The coordination of ideas and expectations about national, regional, and international environmental policy is made easier through networking of civil society. They should also be considered as significant participants in discussions surrounding multinational environmental agreements.

In order to frame environmental policies, one can also follow the U.S. model of environmental law. The U.S. model is notable for its emphasis on promoting civil society involvement in the creation, implementation, and enforcement of environmental policies. Environmental NGOs and politically significant regulated businesses engage in aggressive lobbying in Congress and before agencies.  Before issuing regulations, agencies must ask for and consider public feedback.  Anyone impacted by agency activities has the right to submit a lawsuit to have those acts reviewed by a judge, and regular people and NGOs may also file cases to have U.S. environmental laws enforced.

In accordance with its cultural, religious, and other heritages, civil society fosters ideals, standards, and codes of conduct for behavior of individuals, groups, and organizations. Civil society is the source of voluntary activity, as opposed to governmental regulatory structures. In addition to the government’s efforts to solve political, social, and economic challenges, especially those pertaining to the environment, civil society has a significant role and obligation.

Qurat-Ul-Ain Shabbir is a research officer at the center for International Strategic Studies (CISS) AJK. Currently she is pursuing her PhD degree in DSS from Quaid-i-Azam University. Her areas of interest include contemporary security and security and conflict analysis.





The views and opinions expressed in this article/Opinion/Comment are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the DND Thought Center and Dispatch News Desk (DND). Assumptions made within the analysis are not reflective of the position of the DND Thought Center and Dispatch News Desk News Agency.

Mati-Ullah is the Online Editor For DND. He is the real man to handle the team around the Country and get news from them and provide to you instantly.

Must read

Recent News

Infinix Note 30 Pro Price in Pakistan

Infinix Note 30 Pro Price in Pakistan 2023

Infinix is a brand known for its commitment to providing budget-friendly and future-proof smartphones. One of the standout models in the Infinix smartphone series...
Best formula milk for baby 0-6 months in Pakistan

Best formula milk for baby 0-6 months in Pakistan

You are not alone if you feel confused by the variety of infant milk options. Let me introduce this by saying that there is...
Best places to visit in Switzerland in September

Best places to visit in Switzerland in October

If you're planning a trip to Switzerland in the late summer, September should come to your mind. Up to the start of the ski...
Abdul Sattar Edhi

Abdul Sattar Edhi Biography | Life, Family, Social Work, etc

Abdul Sattar Edhi was known as the Father Teresa of Pakistan because of his selfless social work. He organized the Edhi Foundation which gave...

Focusing on privatisation raises doubts on interim govt’s intent with regard to its tenure:...

Reminds caretaker govt primary mandate to hold free, fair polls within 90 daysISLAMABAD: Pakistan: The Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) Spokesperson made it clear that the...